Test mode — payments in the preview use sandbox cards (try 4242 4242 4242 4242).
· LONG ISLAND'S PUDDING KITCHEN ·

Spoon-deep
happiness.

Classic and low-cal banana pudding - hand-whipped at sunrise, stacked into jars by lunch. Pickup by appointment only.

See the menu →Cater an event
2
flavors, 2 sizes
Long Island
Made Fresh Daily
Soft Cravings logo
Classic Banana 🍌★Low-Cal Banana 🍌★8 oz · 12 oz★Made fresh daily🍌Made on Long Island★Pickup by appointment🏠
Classic Banana 🍌★Low-Cal Banana 🍌★8 oz · 12 oz★Made fresh daily🍌Made on Long Island★Pickup by appointment🏠

The Menu

Pick your craving.

Two banana puddings, two sizes — whipped, layered, and chilled in our Long Island kitchen, never the day before.

Classic BananaSignature

Classic Banana

Vanilla wafers, ripe bananas, cloud-soft cream.

$16
Low-Cal BananaLight

Low-Cal Banana

All the cream, lighter on the sugar. Still feels like dessert.

$18

Since day one

A spoonful of soft, a dose of crave.

Soft Cravings started in the sweetest way — right from my home kitchen on Long Island. One taste with my husband turned into jars shared with friends and family, and the same reaction kept coming back: "You need to sell this." Today every jar is made in a licensed commercial kitchen — still by hand, still in small batches, still with the dream of one day opening our own bakeshop.

100%
Real cream
0
Shortcuts
3 days
Shelf life

Hosting something?

We'll bring the pudding bar.

Drop a branded freezer at your office or gym, stock our jars at your restaurant, or have us cater your wedding, birthday, or corporate event. Jars by the dozen, ready to spoon.

Request a quote →(516) 450-8371
🧊
Freezer placement
Offices, gyms, shops
🎉
Event catering
Weddings, parties, corporate

Pickup by appointment

All orders are pickup by appointment at our kitchen. Order online, schedule a time, then swing by to grab your jars fresh.

  • 🍌 Order online or by phone
  • 🍮 We text you when your jars are ready
  • 🏠 Pick up at 1064 Prospect Ave, Westbury, NY 11590